Why Using AI for Online Dating Is a Terrible Idea
As someone who has been writing dating profiles and working as a dating coach for two decades, I’ve seen every evolutionary stage of online dating. That is why I can say with certainty that using AI to write your dating profiles, pick (and edit) your profile pics, and even write your messages for you, is one of the dumbest things I’ve encountered. When it comes to online dating, AI is heavy on the Artificial, but light on the Intelligence.
AI in Online Dating: What It Really Does
Machine learning has been a part of online dating for years. Several of the biggest dating apps use AI models to tweak the matches they offer you based on who you are swiping right and left on. For example, if you swipe right on lots of redheads, the app will show you more gingers. Or, if you say you are looking for a serious relationship, but you are mainly liking and swiping right on profiles seeking something casual, it will start giving you more casual daters to look at. That’s where AI and machine learning are helpful—but that’s about as far as it goes.
The Problem with AI Profile Writing
AI chatbots like Grok, ChatGPT, and Gemini have plenty of data but zero emotional intelligence. If you’re starting with a truly awful profile, sure, a bot can make it look cleaner—but there’s a big difference between “better than bad” and “good.”
One of the biggest misconceptions about good profiles is thinking that a great one equals tons of responses. In reality, if you’re inundated with messages, there’s a good chance your profile isn’t that great—it’s just too broad. Compatibility isn’t one-size-fits-all. A good profile should connect with your people, not the masses.
That’s where AI fails. Even with great prompts, AI tends to create something generic, safe, and forgettable. When I tested it, every profile came out with the same plastic tone. When I asked why, the AI basically said it tries to make a profile that appeals to the most people possible. That might sound smart—but it kills authenticity. The result? More first dates that go nowhere and missed opportunities with the people who might actually click with you.
If you’re struggling to write something that feels like you, consider professional dating profile writing. A few small changes can make a huge difference.
What AI Misses: Judgment and Context
“Honesty.” Everyone says they want it or says they’re honest. AI will happily include that cliché, not realizing that asking for honesty can make you sound wounded—and saying you’re “very honest” can make you sound untrustworthy.
“Generosity.” AI doesn’t understand subtext. Talking about your generosity makes you sound salesy or desperate. Asking for it can make you look like a gold digger, even if that’s not your intention.
Negativity. People often describe what they want by listing what they don’t want. A human can frame that positively; AI can’t. It parrots back your negatives, which repels emotionally healthy potential matches.
For real-world examples of what works, check out our dating profile tips and examples.
AI Photo Editing: The New Catfish
AI-edited and generated photos are one of the biggest honesty issues in modern dating. Whether it’s removing wrinkles, changing your body, or dropping yourself into exotic vacations, it might look cool—but it’s deceptive. The more different you look online, the faster trust evaporates in person.
Almost every online dater has experienced meeting someone who looks nothing like their pictures. That isn’t success; it’s just creating awkward encounters with people who feel duped. You don’t need AI—or even a professional photographer—to fix this. Usually, it’s lighting, posture, or expression. Spend an afternoon with a friend and a phone camera, and you’ll have authentic, flattering photos that actually look like you.
Why AI Messaging Doesn’t Work
More people are relying on AI to send opening messages, and it’s tanking their chances. AI’s suggestions might sound polished, but they’re also bland and soulless. You can’t fake chemistry with a chatbot. Once your match suspects you’re outsourcing your conversation, you’ve lost all credibility.
People aren’t expecting perfection—they’re expecting something real. It’s better to stumble through your first few messages than to sound like everyone else’s bot-generated text.
The Human Solution: Real Connections Win
If you’re looking for free tools that actually help, Grammarly is a great start. It’ll clean up typos and polish your tone. Beyond that, human feedback is invaluable. Ask a friend to review your profile, share it on dating app subreddits for feedback, or reach out to an online dating coach who understands how to make your personality shine through authentically.
AI in your dating profile is like bad CGI—it looks almost real, until it doesn’t. People connect with people. Using AI just short-circuits your chance to make genuine connections.
Need help creating a dating profile that actually attracts real people?
Our online dating profile experts can help you write and optimize your profile for genuine matches.
Schedule your free consultation today.
